.

Why Marple Newtown Didn't Make AYP For 2011-12

Marple Newtown High School was among the 12 out of 15 high schools in Delaware County to miss the adequate yearly progress targets for the 2011-12 school year.

NEWTOWN SQUARE–Marple Newtown High School was the only school in the Marple Newtown School District unable to meet their AYP (adequately yearly progress) targets, but they weren't the only ones in the county.

According to the Pennsylvania Department of Education, 12 out of the 15 high schools in Delaware County had missed the mark on their AYP targets. The only high schools in the county to meet their targets were Penncrest, Radnor, and Wallingford-Swarthmore.

However, across the commonwealth, fewer and fewer schools are meeting the AYP targets. According to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the "new benchmark shows the percentage of students statewide scoring proficient or advanced declined from 77.1 percent in 2011 to 75.7 percent in 2012 in math. In reading, the decline was from 73.5 percent to 71.9 percent."

In 2010-11, 72 percent of Pennsylvania schools made AYP while in 2011-12, the percentage dropped significantly to 49 percent, according to the Department of Education. And the number of schools on the warning list–including Marple Newtown–more than doubled from 13 percent in 2010-11 to 31 percent in 2011-12.

State's AYP Benchmarks Unfair

Marple Newtown Superintendent of Schools Merle Horowitz shared her disappointment on not making AYP this year, but relayed her frustrations on the state's criteria to determine a school's performance through standardized testing especially with the hard-reaching and ever illusive target goals. It's simply just "not fair," according to Horowitz.

"We're not happy," shared Horowitz over the phone about not making AYP this year, considering the high school made it last year. "It's a big issue. "

The 2012-13 target goals are 91 percent of students advanced or proficient in reading and 89 percent of students advanced or proficient in math. And by 2014, according to the No Child Left Behind Act, all schools must be 100 percent advanced or proficient in both reading and math. 

"Every year the bar jumps to another 10 points," said Horowitz. "And it's getting harder and harder every year."

Although Horowitz takes pride in the diversity within the district, the diversity can also create a few more challenges and criteria to meet.

Subgroups Can Affect Performance

For a school to meet AYP, they must meet all of these three targets: graduation rate/attendance, performance, and participation. However, the number of goals and targets used for AYP can vary by school district.

According to the Department of Education, this is because the measures associated with subgroups (gender, race, special needs students, or English Language Learners) that have fewer than 40 students in the school do not apply. However, schools with fewer than 40 students are still accountable and are evaluated in the All Students Group.

For instance, in Marple Newtown High School, there are more than 40 IEP students, or students with special needs, many of whom attend schools outside the district. However, all of the students are still required to take the PSSA (Pennsylvania System of School Assessment) and their scores are reflected and weighted on the public school. 

According to Horowitz, Paxon Hollow Middle School had nearly 900 students and 21 subgroups taking the PSSA for 2011-12 and they still made AYP. However, Marple Newtown High School's subgroup for IEP students did not make two out of the 15 AYP targets which meant that the high school and district did not make AYP.

Subgroups Can Affect Graduation Rate

According to the Pennsylvania School Boards Association (PSBA), this was the first year in which the Department of Education has calculated graduation rates for subgroups in addition to rates for the school and district. However, under federal law, special education students are allowed to attend public schools until age 21 to ensure they have had an appropriate education.

Marple Newtown High School had approximately 15 students who didn't graduate on time and chose to continue their education. "Unfortunately, that's held against us," states Horowitz. 

"The combined impact of subgroup performance, new graduation rate formulas and leaps in testing performance targets has meant that some schools that historically have made AYP are now falling short of the increased goals further illustrating the fact that NCLB is in desperate need of revision," states the PSBA

Delaware County High Schools Who Didn't Make AYP For 2011-12:

  • Marple Newtown High School – Warning
  • Springfield High School – Warning
  • Haverford High School – School Improvement
  • Garnet Valley – Warning
  • Penn Delco – Warning
  • Chichester – School Improvement
  • Upper Darby – Corrective Action
  • Interboro – Corrective Action
  • Southeast Delco – Corrective Action
  • Chester Upland – Corrective Action
  • William Penn – Corrective Action
  • Ridley – Corrective Action
Newtown Resident September 27, 2012 at 04:23 PM
In the first article you reported that Haverford made AYP. Now this one says it didn't. Which is it?
Jennifer Kim (Editor) September 27, 2012 at 05:14 PM
Correct--first article was that Haverford School District made it. This article is about the high schools, in which Haverford High School didn't make it.
Broomall Resident September 27, 2012 at 05:47 PM
So if Marple High School didn't make AYP and Haverford high school (and others) didn't make AYP... Why did Marple Newtown fail as a district and not the others?
Jennifer Kim (Editor) September 27, 2012 at 06:14 PM
I'm actually not quite sure why Haverford High School didn't make AYP but the district still made it. But I think it's determined on the number of targets that need to be met in each subgroup at each school and in each district. Apparently every school and every district has a different number of targets, which could mean more weight on certain schools. The formula seems pretty complicated on how the state determines who makes AYP and who doesn't. More information here: http://paayp.emetric.net/
Newtown Resident September 28, 2012 at 12:30 AM
Got it now, thanks!

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something